West Ham United 2-2 (2-4p) Leeds United: Forgetting out of time
I'm grateful for Leeds United's stoppage time collapse because it turned this match back towards cup football purity and, while it might not have been romantic, it developed an outsized mental dominance that ensures it won't be easily forgotten.
Leedsista is entirely written by me, a human person, and entirely funded by people like you, Leeds fans, who think decent non-AI, non-clickbait writing about their football team is worth £3 a month to read or £5 a month to listen to the podcast version.
If you enjoy reading what I write, I hope you'll consider becoming a paying member to help keep it getting written.
Find out what you can get with a 30 day free trial:
This tie was a stern test of my faith that kick-off brings clarity to football. I love kick-off because its coming has a calm, clarifying function. The morning of the match unveiling weather, teamsheets printed and players warming up. Ball on centre circle, perhaps huddled round and respected or perhaps not, then a whistle and we're off. And we only want our team to win this game now because wanting any other outcome, once it starts, is absurd.
The thing about football in 2026 is that we've had years fogging up that clarity and I fell into the trap earlier in the season of not wanting to bother with FA Cup football this time. For once I was persuaded by the bigwig's arguments about funding their stadium redevelopments, and my own notions towards Leeds United buying better players in the future for a better team in the future and to keep playing against the best teams in our future. Then again if Frank Lampard can get Coventry promoted at a canter maybe the Championship isn't the fearful flytrap of the mid-2010s anymore and we could dip down again, no harm done. And besides, who says we have to choose, FA Cup or staying up? Why not both? And as winning makes winning easy, let's win.
Ah yes, winning. Easily said, not so easily done, although from 2-0 up in the 93rd minute, you'd think Leeds United would find a simpler way of achieving it. But then you'd remember how Leeds United love to find the hard way.
In a way I'm grateful for Leeds United's stoppage time collapse because it turned this match back towards cup football purity and, while it might not have been romantic, it developed an outsized mental dominance that ensures it won't be easily forgotten. The FA Cup is all about making memories, right? Well, I think I'll always remember this match, the way I'll always remember Leeds United 2-4 Derby County from May 2019. I always say that's one of my favourite matches, because how many football fans get to say they lived through something like that?
At West Ham, in this FA Cup quarter-final, Leeds United took my nerves on a journey to the other side of cup football purity and back again until, after three hours, all I wanted was for Pascal Struijk to blast his penalty past the 'orrible oik who'd gone in their goal and get the Peacocks to Wembley. And I got what I wanted in the end, so all was well that ended well.
Read the whole history (of hating Port Vale)
4.8/5 on Amazon, 1,400 reviews | 4.6/5 on Goodreads, 282 reviews
'A sports book that left me reading under the lamplight at 1am and begging for more at the end of every chapter. Unheard of'
I would have been content with the match finishing when it should have, without the signalling of eleven added minutes giving the Hammers encouragement for one more go at getting back into the game. But I wasn't truly satisfied by the prospect of that 2-0 win, because too much else had been allowed in.
Sure, the game had got to the point where Wilf Gnonto was backheeling just wide and Sebastiaan Bornauw was taking long range shots. The Peacocks had earned the right to party by dominating West Ham among the rolling lawns of their gigantic back yard. Ao Tanaka had started and finished a first half move, opening the scoring by being determined to score and twisting and turning in the Hammers' box until his deflected shot went in off the bar. Dominic Calvert-Lewin doubled the lead with fifteen minutes left after Brenden Aaronson was given a replica of the penalty Anton Stach should have got in the first half, courtesy of Max Kilman's flying tackling.
Leeds were better than West Ham but, hard as I tried to resist it, that meant implications for the Premier League were flickering through my mind. Kilman's first foul had bent the ligaments of Anton Stach. Joe Rodon had finally turned out to be as injured as he looked and went off. Noah Okafor, who brought welcome new pace and thrust to United's attack, wandered away feeling his hamstrings. Leeds started the second half looking worried, misplacing passes, letting the Hammers into the game: for ten minutes before the second goal, when Valentín Castellanos headed one cross against the post and more and more crosses kept coming, an equaliser felt inevitable and felt, to me, portentous for the relegation battle to come. Momentum, in those minutes, was swinging from West Yorkshire to East London, and not just for the day.
Momentum, after that, was all over the bloody shop. Leeds' second goal let them clamp down on West Ham and have fun, but with an unexpected extra tenth of a match offered to them Jarrod Bowen and Adama Traoré remembered how good they are going forward and stopped worrying about how bad their defensive colleagues are. Leeds, ready for the game to be over, succumbed to Bowen's shot off the post being bundled in by Mateus Fernandes, and to Axel Disasi not being punished for kicking Struijk in the head as he struck the ball in to equalise.
Extra-time brought more on the same theme. Lucas Perri started with a panicked choice of head over hands, letting Castellanos in to spark wild celebrations among the West Ham fans who had stuck around. Perhaps they wished they were anywhere else when VAR ruled that out for offside, and another from Pablo after another shot from Bowen came back off another post. This was bad, from a Leeds United point of view. But from a magic of the cup point of view it was good, because I had long since given up caring about any relegation implications of this game. I just wanted it over and I just wanted Leeds to win.
It felt unlikely as penalty kicks approached. The second half of extra-time was dominated by the sound of history books being dredged up from under the old Boleyn Ground, fresh pages being dusted off, bottles of squid ink being shaken up ready. West Ham's goalie was injured. His only available replacement was Finlay Herrick, a twenty-year-old without a senior West Ham appearance who was recently on loan at Boreham Wood. The raw kid pulled his gloves on and went out to face the shoot-out, ready to be the Hammers' new cup hero, a Mervyn Day to be, and started with a save: he blocked Joel Piroe's tame effort.
And he seemed to be a total prick. I doubt even the most die-hard cup romantic could keep fingers crossed for his underdog moment while he milked that save, gurned and yelled at Leeds' subsequent takers, and arrogantly pantomimed that he was 'this close' to stopping the shots flying past him into the net. Chest out, puffed up, he was disillusioning every old ideal of youth team footballers by showing off the downsides of having your ego and bank balance inflated from the moment you hit your teens. I'm sure that, in his mind, trash-talking Calvert-Lewin as he ran up to take his penalty was a good idea. Calvert-Lewin, after scoring, turned away and never looked back to see Herrick miming that he'd nearly saved it, already never thinking about him ever again. Herrick wore a very different face once four penalties had gone clear past him and the game was all up.
And Leeds are off to Wembley. An FA Cup semi-final! I might soon be thinking about the Premier League again, and Leeds and West Ham's positions within it, and along these lines: yes, Leeds did very Leeds things in this game, but look at West Ham. Getting back to 2-2, getting the ball in the net twice more, setting up a hero story for Herrick, and losing. I love that for them, and will file it along with their famous game at Stamford Bridge a while ago, when they led 2-0 at half-time and lost 3-2 to a 92nd minute goal; to the lead they lost at Old Trafford ten days after that, in the 96th minute; to the lead they let slip twice in the last round of the cup against Brentford; to how poor they were against Aston Villa in their last match and how much pressure is on them, this Friday, at home to Wolves.
Herrick helped me forget about all that, though. The West Ham fans locked outside through extra-time, not allowed back after leaving at 0-2, helped. Danny Dyer's disappointment helped. The refereeing helped, the way it didn't favour Leeds; Lucas Perri helped, the way two great saves were followed by mad and awful moments that were followed by the shootout winning saves. Anton Stach's injury helped because it's not a big cup win if someone isn't celebrating on crutches. Extra-time helped because it was like a long, drawn-out, thirty minute kick-off, forcing us to concentrate on this game and this game only and on getting to the FA Cup semi-finals for the first time since 1987. If our romancing of the cup had to have the acrimonious taste of these three topsy-turvy hours, well, I remember 1998 when Don Goodman scored for Wolves in an FA Cup quarter-final at Elland Road and Jimmy Hasselbaink missed a penalty while Kevin Muscat flung mud at him. So this one is for them, too. ⭑彡
Leedsista newsletter
Free, independent writing about Super Leeds in your inbox
"We were very pleased when we heard Leeds would be our opponents," said Victor. "They are the weakest team in the competition, and we've got the easiest draw."
Coming from Celtic as United's main summer signing, with Champions League experience behind him, Darren O'Dea was lumbered with the impossible task of bringing stability to an increasingly chaotic club.
New! Hoodies! Money off mugs!
Free members of Leedsista can get £1 off a Leedsista mug (as many times as they like. Paying members can get £2 off. If that's you, check your emails for the codes — if you wish that was you, you can join Leedsista by clicking here.